X-Authentication-Warning: delorie.com: mail set sender to geda-user-bounces using -f X-Recipient: geda-user AT delorie DOT com X-Mailer: exmh version 2.8.0 04/21/2012 with nmh-1.6 X-Exmh-Isig-CompType: repl X-Exmh-Isig-Folder: inbox From: karl AT aspodata DOT se To: geda-user AT delorie DOT com Subject: Re: [geda-user] Another PCB grid step question In-reply-to: References: <6221de93-bb98-d397-79b4-eecf3975c2e6 AT linetec DOT nl>

<20180209161532 DOT 6AF57804CEFA AT turkos DOT aspodata DOT se> Comments: In-reply-to gedau AT igor2 DOT repo DOT hu message dated "Fri, 09 Feb 2018 18:13:27 +0100." Mime-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset="utf-8" Message-Id: <20180209204934.CAA35804CEFA@turkos.aspodata.se> Date: Fri, 9 Feb 2018 21:49:34 +0100 (CET) X-Virus-Scanned: ClamAV using ClamSMTP Reply-To: geda-user AT delorie DOT com Errors-To: nobody AT delorie DOT com X-Mailing-List: geda-user AT delorie DOT com X-Unsubscribes-To: listserv AT delorie DOT com Precedence: bulk Igor2: ... > On Fri, 9 Feb 2018, karl AT aspodata DOT se wrote: ... > > $ pcb-rnd -V > > pcb-rnd version 1.2.7 rev svn r14602 > > $ cp original.pcb tt.pcb > > $ pcb-rnd -gui lesstif tt.pcb > > adding a line > > File->save layout > > > > $ diff tt.pcb original.pcb > > > > 880c871 > > < Element["" "apem_3mek_sc.fp" "M2" "unknown" 92.75mm 71.25mm -18.75mm -15.5mm 0 100 "floater"] > > --- > >> Element["lock" "apem_3mek_sc.fp" "M2" "unknown" 92.7500mm 71.2500mm -18.7500mm -15.5000mm 0 100 ""] > > 882,893c873,881 > > < Attribute("footprint" "apem_3mek_sc.fp") > > < Attribute("refdes" "M2") > > < Attribute("value" "unknown") > > > > $ pcb tt.pcb > > ERROR parsing file 'tt.pcb' > > line: 844 > > description: 'Unknown flag: "floater" ignored' > > ERROR parsing file 'tt.pcb' > > line: 880 > > description: 'Unknown flag: "floater" ignored' > > ERROR parsing file 'tt.pcb' > > line: 897 > > description: 'Unknown flag: "floater" ignored' > > Thanks for reporting, worked around in r14603. > > (The real fix would be to upgrade pcb with the flag compat patch, back > from 2013 - but I gave up on trying to get it applied back in 2015) You mean this: http://www.delorie.com/archives/browse.cgi?p=geda-user/2013/09/01/02:49:59 Yes, wouldn't mind that, but Richards problem was to cooperate with the pcb programs run by his fellow designers, i.e. make it work with older versions of pcb. > > pcb: rtree.c:1054: r_insert_entry: Assertion `which->X1 <= which->X2' failed. > > Aborted ... > However, the assert is a bug in pcb - it should not assert even on invalid > input. Perhaps, but it does in the debug version, and the problem was: can Richard save files from pcb-rnd and give them to his co-workers ? > If it doesn't like negative coords in some fields, Soo, what do a "thickness" of -2mm mean ? Here is the first pad in tt.pcb: $ grep -B10 Pad tt.pcb |head | grep Element Element["" "m3216_a.fp" "m5R1" "1k" 159.5mm 67.55mm 1750.0um -7.05mm 2 100 "auto,floater"] grep -A10 '"m5R1"' tt.pcb > t.fp grep -A14 '"m5R1"' original.pcb > o.fp $ cat o.fp Element["onsolder" "m3216_a.fp" "m5R1" "1k" 159.5000mm 67.5500mm 1.7500mm -7.0500mm 2 100 "onsolder"] ( Attribute("device" "Resistor") Attribute("manufacturer" "unknown") Attribute("manufacturer_part_number" "unknown") Attribute("vendor" "unknown") Attribute("vendor_part_number" "unknown") Pad[-0.3500mm 1.5500mm 0.3500mm 1.5500mm 1.3000mm 0.5000mm 1.5000mm "1" "1" "onsolder,square"] Pad[-0.3500mm -1.5500mm 0.3500mm -1.5500mm 1.3000mm 0.5000mm 1.5000mm "2" "2" "onsolder,square"] ElementLine [-1.2600mm -2.4600mm -1.2600mm 2.4600mm 0.3200mm] ElementLine [-1.2600mm -2.4600mm 1.2600mm -2.4600mm 0.3200mm] ElementLine [1.2600mm -2.4600mm 1.2600mm 2.4600mm 0.3200mm] ElementLine [-1.2600mm 2.4600mm 1.2600mm 2.4600mm 0.3200mm] ) $ cat t.fp Element["" "m3216_a.fp" "m5R1" "1k" 159.5mm 67.55mm 1750.0um -7.05mm 2 100 "auto,floater"] ( Attribute("footprint" "m3216_a.fp") Attribute("refdes" "m5R1") Attribute("value" "1k") Attribute("device" "Resistor") Attribute("manufacturer" "unknown") Attribute("manufacturer_part_number" "unknown") Attribute("vendor" "unknown") Attribute("vendor_part_number" "unknown") Pad[0.0 1200.0um 0.0 1900.0um -2.0mm 250.0um -2.0mm "1" "1" "square"] Pad[0.0 -1900.0um 0.0 -1200.0um -2.0mm 250.0um -2.0mm "2" "2" "square"] ) 1, silk lines is missing from the pcb-rnd saved element 2. pcb-rnd creates attributes which it later complains about: $ pcb-rnd --gui lesstif t.fp mutliple values for attribute footprint: 'm3216_a.fp' and 'm3216_a.fp' - ignoring 'm3216_a.fp' mutliple values for attribute footprint: 'm3216_a.fp' and 'm3216_a.fp' - ignoring 'm3216_a.fp' mutliple values for attribute refdes: 'm5R1' and 'm5R1' - ignoring 'm5R1' mutliple values for attribute refdes: 'm5R1' and 'm5R1' - ignoring 'm5R1' mutliple values for attribute value: '1k' and '1k' - ignoring '1k' mutliple values for attribute value: '1k' and '1k' - ignoring '1k' No preferred unit format info available for 't.fp' - will use 'geda/pcb - readable units' on save (guessed from non-nanometer explicit unit usage) No preferred unit format info available for 't.fp' - will use 'geda/pcb - readable units' on save (guessed from non-nanometer explicit unit usage) Loaded menu file '/usr/local/share/pcb-rnd/pcb-menu-lesstif.lht' 3. original clearance is 0.5mm, pcb-rnd converts that to 0.25mm 4. I don't really know how to treat a mask value of -2mm, the orig. is 1.5mm 5. theese are supposed to be the same, care to tell me how: Pad[-0.3500mm 1.5500mm 0.3500mm 1.5500mm 1.3000mm 0.5000mm 1.5000mm "1" "1" "onsolder,square"] Pad[-0.3500mm -1.5500mm 0.3500mm -1.5500mm 1.3000mm 0.5000mm 1.5000mm "2" "2" "onsolder,square"] Pad[0.0 1200.0um 0.0 1900.0um -2.0mm 250.0um -2.0mm "1" "1" "square"] Pad[0.0 -1900.0um 0.0 -1200.0um -2.0mm 250.0um -2.0mm "2" "2" "square"] > it should > probably check for those and give a meaningful error message. ... Ack. Regards, /Karl Hammar ----------------------------------------------------------------------- Aspö Data Lilla Aspö 148 S-742 94 Östhammar Sweden +46 173 140 57