From:	Dead_and_gone <alaric AT novia DOT net>
Newsgroups:	rec.games.programmer,comp.os.msdos.djgpp
Subject:	Re: C++ compilers / will somebody please verify or deny this
Date:	Wed, 08 Jan 1997 15:03:06 -0600
Organization:	Novia Internetworking <> 33.6kbps dialup; 402/390-2NET
Lines:	47
Message-ID:	<32D40B8A.4180@novia.net>
References:	<01bbf8fc$1b66f580$5c7da3ce AT nicks> <32CC9574 DOT 4238 AT student DOT hk-r DOT se> <32CD0431 DOT 5763 AT novia DOT net> <32cd45dc DOT 1977986 AT news DOT cancom DOT net> <32CD57E7 DOT 7A97 AT stud DOT warande DOT ruu DOT nl> <32CDF55F DOT CBC AT novia DOT net> <32CE174D DOT 1250 AT stud DOT warande DOT ruu DOT nl> <32D01D94 DOT 656D AT gpu DOT srv DOT ualberta DOT ca>
NNTP-Posting-Host:	shadowwing.novia.net
Mime-Version:	1.0
To:	djgpp AT delorie DOT com
DJ-Gateway:	from newsgroup comp.os.msdos.djgpp

Jens Vaasjo wrote:
> 
> Elliott Oti wrote:
> >
> > The Cygnus GnuWin site specifically states that the required libraries
> > are GNU Copyleft, and as such fall under the restrictions placed on
> > commercial use. They offer no alternative non-copylefted libraries
> > for use.
> >
> > djgpp itself is Copyleft, but the GNU C/C++ libraries (with the exception of
> > iostream) are not. Object code linked with these libraries is not copylefted
> > and can be disposed of as desired.
> >
> > Cygnus GnuWin is a completely separate product from djgpp, although it shares
> > a common origin. Quake was not linked with GnuWin libraries.
> >
> > I cannot remember the specs directly for RNTSXDJ, but methinks the required
> > libraries are also copylefted.
> >
> > Elliott
> 
> Unfortunatly the author of RSXNTDJ has forced all programs written
> with it to link with the import library for their .dll, which makes
> you have to redistrubute the .dll with any app you write. And the guy
> charges a lincencing fee of $20 to redistrubute this .dll with your app.
> 
> With Cygnus they force you to link with the import library for there
> .dll which is under GNU GPL which puts any app you write under
> GNU GPL.
> 
> So with the 2 free win32 compilers, both force you to link to the
> import library for there .dll, so both force you to redistrubute
> their .dll's with your apps, which for Cygnus puts your app under GPL
> and for RSXNTDJ forces you to pay a redistrubution fee.
> 
> Also on these not supporting DirectX, DirectX is realy just a bunch
> of .dll's and header files and RSXNTDJ comes with a utility called
> MAKELIB which behaves like Borlands IMPLIB so RSXNTDJ like any
> other compiler with such a utility can create the required import
> librarys for any .dll (including ddraw.dll and so on).
> 
> By the way its actually linking with libgpp.a that puts apps
> written with djgpp under GNU GPL.
> 
> Jens.

Will somebody please confirm or deny this I son't think this is right!

- Raw text -