Mail Archives: cygwin/2010/04/10/23:22:12
Norton Allen <allen AT huarp DOT harvard DOT edu> writes:
> On 4/9/2010 5:56 AM, Paul Bibbings wrote:
>> If by "add a right-click context menu to the spinner" you intend to
>> retain the current problematic behaviour of the spinner but add the
>> context menu by way of avoiding the noted problems of cycling through
>> `uninstall', then I would, as a user, see that as an inconsistency. I
>> would expect the two to be alternative ways of achieving the same thing
>> and regard the (presumably) silent difference to be a design flaw. I may
>> be missing something, but I'm wondering how it is that, if the pass
>> through `install' can put in all the dependencies, continuing to
>> `uninstall' can't just take them out again?
>>
> So what you want setup to do is remember whether a package was selected
> by the user or simply included to satisfy a dependency. Then when a
> package is deselected, the dependencies can be reevaluated.
Although I hadn't considered it fully when I wrote the above, this idea
certainly emerged as one that addresses a valid use case, the more I
thought about it. Having said that, the more that I /have/ thought
about it, the more the set of valid use-cases seems to grow and the
whole thing starts to look horribly complex. Not that I'm wanting to
suggest that all `valid' (whatever that means) use cases /should/ be
accommodated. Like any maintenance project, if no-one's asking for it,
don't add it.
On a related note, it does seem that the current implementation is quite
geared towards the user simply making choices and then proceeding
straight to next. It's when a user changes their mind, or performs other
actions before proceeding to next that issues seem to arise. For
instance, if I click on the view button and select `Not installed',
suppose I select a package that I don't have - for example (I'm trying
this now), aspell-dev 0.60.5-1. Then, suppose I merely cycle through
the Views and come back to `Not installed'. aspell-dev is no longer in
the list, despite the fact that I have not done anything other than
change the view. It is no more installed now than it was before.
Regards
Paul Bibbings
--
Problem reports: http://cygwin.com/problems.html
FAQ: http://cygwin.com/faq/
Documentation: http://cygwin.com/docs.html
Unsubscribe info: http://cygwin.com/ml/#unsubscribe-simple
- Raw text -