Mail Archives: cygwin/2009/11/17/14:11:59
2009/11/17 Eric Blake:
> Thomas Wolff writes:
>
>> Sorry that I take this up once more (after promising <end:of>), but I
>> had this additional idea after seeing your point about being strictly
>> consistent with the POSIX pathname namespace:
>>
>> So what about using "/" as a delimiter? If "foo" is a file, "foo/bar" is
>> not a legal pathname in POSIX, so it could be used to access the "bar"
>> fork of "foo" without causing real harm.
>
> NO - a thousand times no. =C2=A0Using / in file names, but not as a direc=
tory, is
> just ASKING to break everything ever written, and penalize speed of inter=
faces
> that could care less about this.
>
> But, you _could_ borrow a leaf from Solaris, and support and implementati=
on:
>
> openat(open("foo",flags), "bar", flags)
>
> as a way to open the "bar" stream of the "foo" fd, aka "foo:bar" in windo=
ws
> terms. =C2=A0In other words, open("foo/bar") MUST fail, because foo is no=
t a
> directory, but openat(fd_of_foo,"bar") is an extension allowed by POSIX (=
just
> because we currently fail with ENOTDIR in that situation doesn't mean we =
have
> to); and by using the *at interfaces, we could isolate the performance pe=
nalty
> to just the situations where the fd is not a directory fd.
>
> You would also want to consider implementing opendir2 (borrowing from BSD
> heritage; there, opendir2 exists to allow the user to select whether whit=
eout
> entries in a union mount will be ignored), and adding a new DTF_* bit that
> allows opening a file to traverse its alternate streams, instead of the n=
ormal
> opening a directory to traverse its contents.
Another example to throw in the mix: OS X. It represents named forks
on HFS+ volumes like this:
<filename>/..namedforks/<fork>
I guess the '..namedforks' bit is there so that
'opendir("<filename>")' can fail as usual, whereas
'opendir("<filename>/..namedforks")' will get at the list of forks in
the file.
Andy
--
Problem reports: http://cygwin.com/problems.html
FAQ: http://cygwin.com/faq/
Documentation: http://cygwin.com/docs.html
Unsubscribe info: http://cygwin.com/ml/#unsubscribe-simple
- Raw text -