Mail Archives: cygwin/2007/05/01/10:21:44
On Tue, May 01, 2007 at 09:59:24AM -0400, Charles Wilson wrote:
>Christopher Faylor wrote:
>>Before you do this, I have a question. Why is this important now when
>>you've
>>apparently been doing this for many years? This isn't the only package
>>which
>>makes symlinks to executables. And, since, AFAIK, setup.exe doesn't
>>understand
>>hard links it means that you really do have to make a copy. If you make a
>>copy
>>you stand the chance of having python.exe out of sync with the thing that
>>it is
>>supposed to be pointing to.
>>
>>If it was a general Cygwin policy to always make copies, I could see
>>changing
>>Python. But, again, since it isn't, I don't see why python should be
>>unique.
>
>Because python is a command interpreter, and therefore likely to be
>invoked directly from the windows environment -- unlike, say, egrep.
>Similarly, sh.exe is a copy of bash.exe (and used to be a copy of
>ash.exe) -- and not a symlink.
I really don't think it's more likely for python to be invoked from the
MS-DOS command line than it is for egrep. I think it would be quite the
reverse in fact. I very rarely invoke python or perl as anything other
than a #! script but I use grep every day from the command line and in
scripts.
And, of course, how often have we seen cases where sh.exe was
"inexplicably" not the right version?
>I think this copy (or hardlink) should be performed by a postinstall
>script -- again, just like sh.exe is updated by bash packages.
We'll have to agree to disagree then. I think a postinstall step for
this is a band-aid. If a hard link is required (and I'm not convinced
that it is) then it's time to bite the bullet and implement it in
setup.exe. I think it's especially bad for python since the whole
reason for the symlink is to allow a versioned python and you lose that
information with a post-install step.
OTOH, I still don't see any reason not to tell people "you have to run
bash first if you want to use python". I believe that the vast majority
of people who use Cygwin always invoke click on the cygwin icon and, so,
would never even notice this.
cgf
--
Unsubscribe info: http://cygwin.com/ml/#unsubscribe-simple
Problem reports: http://cygwin.com/problems.html
Documentation: http://cygwin.com/docs.html
FAQ: http://cygwin.com/faq/
- Raw text -